Born on Lake Michigan · Since 2015

Your shoreline,
built to last a lifetime.

Serving St. Joseph, MI lakefront homeowners with permanent and seasonal docks, steel and vinyl seawalls, boat lifts, certified commercial diving, premium decking, and full-service general contracting since 2015. Family-owned. Licensed and insured. We're the team behind the Library Historic Hotel restoration on Main Street.

Scroll
★★★★★ Five-Star Rated Licensed & Fully Insured St. Joseph · Bridgman · New Buffalo Family-Owned Since 2015
10+Years on the Lake
500+Projects Completed
2States Served
100%Satisfaction Pledge
What We Build

Full-service marine construction —
from waterline to waterfront.

Whether you need a seasonal dock installed before Memorial Day in St. Joseph, a permanent pile-driven dock for your Bridgman lakefront, a steel seawall to hold back Lake Michigan, or a custom barndominium in Berrien County — Captain's Choice handles it all in-house. One team. One contract. One point of accountability across SW Michigan and NW Indiana.

The Library Historic Hotel exterior with Captain's Choice general contractor signage
Featured Project
Trusted with Landmarks

The Library Historic Hotel.

Captain's Choice is providing general contracting on the restoration of St. Joseph's 1903 Andrew Carnegie library — a 120-year-old red brick neoclassical landmark now being reborn as a boutique hotel with curated suites and the Archive Lounge speakeasy.

It's the same precision we bring to every dock, seawall, and lakefront home — whether the canvas is a private shoreline or a piece of Michigan history.

View The Library Project →
Where We Work

Serving Lake Michigan's southern shore
and SW Michigan's inland lakes.

Based in Bridgman, we travel throughout Berrien, Cass, and St. Joseph counties — plus Northwest Indiana.

St. JosephBerrien County
Benton HarborBerrien County
BridgmanBerrien County
New BuffaloBerrien County
South HavenVan Buren County
StevensvilleBerrien County
Sister LakesCass County
Michigan City, INLaPorte County
Our Process

How we work — clear, honest, on schedule.

No high-pressure sales. No surprise change orders. Just straightforward Lake Michigan craftsmanship.

Free Site Visit

We meet you at the water, walk the property, and take exact measurements. No charge, no obligation.

Detailed Quote

You get a transparent, line-item proposal within 5 business days — including materials, timeline, and permit notes.

Build Phase

Our crew handles permits, install, and cleanup. We communicate weekly so you always know where things stand.

Season After Season

For seasonal docks and lifts, we handle install, removal, and storage every year. Set it and forget it.

Why Captain's Choice

A team you can actually reach — for a build that actually lasts.

  • Owner-on-site

    Nick is on every project — not behind a desk. You get the owner's eye on every detail.

  • Certified Commercial Divers

    Most contractors farm diving out. We do it in-house — faster turnarounds, lower costs.

  • Marine + General Contracting

    We're the rare team that can build your dock and remodel your lake house. One crew, one point of contact.

  • Lake Michigan-Tested

    We know what wind, ice, and 6-foot waves do to a shoreline. We build for it — not against it.

St. Joseph · Berrien County

Your local St. Joseph contractor.

St. Joseph is the heart of our service area — home of Silver Beach, the iconic St. Joseph North Pier Lighthouse, and dozens of Lake Michigan bluff-front properties we've worked on. From our work as general contractor on The Library Historic Hotel restoration on Main Street to the cable-rail composite decks lining the lakefront homes above the bluff, we know every block of the city.

Client Stories

What our neighbors say.

Real reviews from lakefront homeowners across Berrien, Cass, and LaPorte counties.

★★★★★
"Nick and his team replaced our seawall after the 2024 storm season took out 40 feet of shoreline. Crew was on-time, on-budget, and the wall looks better than the original."
JM
Jim & Maria T. St. Joseph, MI · Seawall Replacement
★★★★★
"We've used Captain's Choice for our seasonal dock for four years running. They show up when they say they will, no chasing them down. Rare these days."
RK
Rob K. South Haven, MI · Seasonal Dockage
★★★★★
"They installed a permanent dock and a tritoon lift for us last spring. Quality of the work is genuinely impressive — and Nick stayed personally involved start to finish."
SH
Sarah H. New Buffalo, MI · Dock & Lift Install
Get Started

Ready to plan your project?

Tell us a bit about your property and what you'd like to build. We'll set up a free on-site visit and have a detailed quote in your inbox within five business days.

Or call us directly (269) 422-7246

Request a Free Quote